An Amish Murder (2013)

In the tranquil heartland of Painters Mill, an Ohio Amish village, a serenity is shattered by the malevolent presence of the 'Slaughterhouse' serial killer. This shadow from the past resurfaces, leaving a chilling Roman numeral as his signature, suggesting either his ominous return or the emergence of a deadly copycat. This case once left the stern John Tomasetti emotionally scarred, reducing him to an informal advisor and secret lover to the new Chief of Police, the resolute Katie Burkholder. A native of the Amish community, Katie had chosen the allure of the 'English' life, learning the ropes of detective work in the bustling city of Cleveland, only to return to her roots as a beacon of justice. When Mayor Auggie Brock's niece, Amanda, becomes the latest victim, the community's faith in Katie wavers, leading to her suspension and the passing of the investigation torch to the senior deputy, Nathan Detrick. As the clandestine trio of law enforcers contemplates the true identity of the killer, the tranquil Amish community is rocked by revelations from the past. These revelations strike close to home for Katie, unearthing emotional turmoil involving her abandoned Amish lover and her own family. However, the police staff is not without skeletons in their closet, and as Katie inches closer to solving the case, a dark secret threatens to engulf her. In a dramatic turn of events, Katie must confront her past and the choices she made. She's determined to halt the sinister killer before another innocent life is taken. Yet, in doing so, she risks betraying her family, her Amish past, and unveiling a dark secret that could potentially shatter her world. Will the grim truth help bring the killer to justice, or will it destroy the very fabric of the peaceful farming community of Painters Mill? The suspense unfolds as Katie grapples with her past and present, in a desperate race against time.

An Amish Murder is a drama movie featuring Neve Campbell.

An Amish Murder is currently streaming on DIRECTV, Hulu and Lifetime Movie Club.

It is also possible to buy An Amish Murder on Amazon Video and Microsoft Store.